Guide: Ontario health sector

AI scribe governance for Ontario clinics under PHIPA

By Unika Hypolite, Founder & Managing Director. Last reviewed .

Yes, an Ontario clinic can use an AI scribe, and PHIPA applies in full when it does. The IPC's January 2026 guidance expects a governance framework, vendor checks, data minimization and, in most cases, patient consent. Picking a vendor from the provincial list helps, but it doesn't do that work for you.

What the IPC expects

On January 28, 2026 the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (IPC) published AI Scribes: Key Considerations for the Health Sector, with a checklist. The guidance isn't binding. But it tells you how the regulator will read PHIPA when something goes wrong. The checklist has four parts:

  1. An AI governance and accountability framework. Someone owns the decision, the risks are documented, and affected patients are informed.
  2. Duties for developers who build AI scribes.
  3. Duties when you procure one: vet the vendor, and make sure any sharing of health information complies with PHIPA.
  4. Duties when you use one: notes are accurate and reviewed, records are stored securely, consent is valid, and patients are told about the AI, its risks and their alternatives.

Law firms reading the guidance add two practical points. Ban the vendor from using your recordings or notes to train its models, in the contract and in the system settings. Do a privacy impact assessment, plus an algorithmic impact assessment if the scribe will also support clinical decisions.

The provincial vendor list is a start, not a sign-off

The Ontario AI Scribe Program launched in June 2025. Supply Ontario runs its vendor of record list with the Ministry of Health, Ontario Health and OntarioMD. Using it gets you pre-vetted vendors and discounted pricing.

The Auditor General's May 2026 report on AI in government shows why that isn't enough. In the vendor evaluation, note accuracy was worth 20 of 530 points. All 20 approved vendors produced at least one error on two test recordings. Nine invented content, and twelve recorded the wrong drug. Eleven of the 20 hadn't submitted a SOC 2 Type 2, HITRUST or ISO 27001 report and were approved anyway. Supply Ontario has agreed to add minimum scores and stronger security checks to future rounds.

So treat the list as a shortlist. The duty to check accuracy, security and contract terms stays with you as the custodian.

The tool you didn't approve is the bigger risk

Ontario's best-known AI scribe breach didn't involve an approved product. In September 2024 a former physician's personal Otter.ai account joined a hospital's virtual hepatology rounds through an old calendar invite. It recorded the meeting and emailed a summary and transcript to the invite list. Nobody knew it was there until that email arrived.

The IPC's October 2025 response asked the hospital to request deletion from the vendor itself, tighten its breach protocol and fix how it removes departing staff from systems and invites. Notice where the failure sat. It was a governance gap, not a technology one. If your policy only covers the scribe you bought, it misses this case entirely.

A 30-day governance plan for a clinic

  1. Name one accountable lead for AI tools, usually the privacy officer or the medical director.
  2. Publish an approved-tools list and block consumer transcription tools on clinic devices and accounts.
  3. Check the vendor in writing: where data is stored, how long audio is kept, no model training on your data, deletion on request, and a current SOC 2 Type 2 or equivalent report.
  4. Complete a privacy impact assessment before go-live.
  5. Write a consent script and a chart field to record consent and refusal.
  6. Require clinician sign-off on every AI-drafted note, and audit a sample each month for errors.
  7. Add AI to off-boarding and your breach playbook, so departing staff lose access to meetings and the clinic can demand deletion from a vendor fast.

CINTA designs the governance, policy and staff adoption work, and runs shadow AI audits to find the tools already in use. Your privacy counsel signs off on the legal position.

This page explains the rules in plain language. It is not legal or medical advice. CINTA is not a law firm and works alongside your privacy counsel. Related: AI scribes in our FAQ and Digital Strategy & Responsible Innovation.

Facilitating Success

Find out where your gaps are

Every engagement starts with a 90-minute Ecosystem Mapping Session. Bring your current policies and tool list.

Book your Ecosystem Mapping Session